Update 2012: Click here for a 2012 update on the Post-9/11 GI Bill for business school. The original article follows...
It is the finally the official start of the Post 9/11 GI-Bill, and I am still trying to differentiate fact and fiction. Now that the facts are getting clearer, the GI Bill is becoming more and more of a disappointment if one wishes to attend HBS. It appears that because of the language of the bill, one will actually receive more tuition assistance at an overall lower cost school than one will at Harvard. Support for other schools can range significantly. I'll explain...
The GI Bill pays for two categories: tuition and fees. While these are often grouped together, they are in fact two separate accounts. Many public schools keep tuition rates artificially low, and hide the costs in "fees." If you are reading this, you probably already know that the GI Bill is supposed to pay up to the maximum in-state public school tuition plus fees of the state to which you plan to go to school. So let's look at Massachusetts as an example.
In Massachusetts, the most expensive in-state public school is University of Massachusetts at Amherst, and it lists its tuition/fees at $11,732. So how much do you get for HBS? Well, the University apparently only charges $71.50 per credit hour because most of the costs are in "fees." HBS counts as 16 credit hours per term, so one receives 16 x $71.50 for tuition assistance per semester at HBS. That's $1144 in tuition assistance per semester with 100% coverage of the new GI Bill. HBS tuition by the way, is $46,150. As you can imagine, I was rather disappointed to find this out. There is of course housing allowance on top of that, Yellow Ribbon program for those who qualify, and "fees" that get covered on top of tuition. I compiled a list of top 20 schools and calculated everything based on my best understanding of the bill. Please note the following figures are based on my own personal research, and you should follow up with the VA and your school of choice to verify any changes and complete accuracy.
UPDATE 8/31/09: VA raised its Massachusetts tuition credit from $71.50 to $330. This reflects an increase from $1144 in tuition assistance to $5280 per term. Updated numbers are reflected below.
What about the extra "max fees" per term? Well, Massachusetts max fees are $17,787 per term. However, since HBS has relatively low fees (most of the cost is in tuition), you get only the Program Fee, Analytics Support Fee, and Health Insurance covered. That's still a lot better than nothing, but the rather complicated framework of the GI Bill will definitely benefit some schools over others (based on their geographic location and finance structure).
If you do not qualify for 100% of the GI Bill, take the percentage you do qualify for and multiply that by the "1 year total w/o Yellow Ribbon" column below. If you qualify for 100%, you can generally count on the total amount in the far right column. This information is not official and is just based on my personal research...


If anyone has an update to the above numbers or corrections, please let me know and I will update the tables. The Yellow Ribbon program numbers were taken off the VA web site, and it's possible it's not completely updated.
There is one additional benefit to consider, and that is the school "fees." Most likely, all or most of your school "fees" will be covered, but you can check the coverage here to make sure. HBS charges approximately $9,000 a year in fees (including health coverage), so you can add that to the benefit numbers. Fees, as separate from tuition, are not normally broken down on school web site, so contact the school of your choice for specific details. As a rule of thumb though, school fees for top MBA school will probably be in the $3000-$10000 range. These fees will therefore in general be covered in addition to the benefits listed above.
Update (12/29/2010): Update GI Bill number for business school


This was a great timely post. I've been reading your blog from the start and it's probably the most analytical and well written among the dozens of MBA applicant blogs I've seen (I may be biased as a current military applicant). I feel your frustration with the limits of the new GI Bill because I'm interested in MIT and Berkeley, which are both near the bottom in terms of benefit. Keep up the good work.
ReplyDeleteThanks... I'm glad it's helping out. Best of luck in your applications!
ReplyDeleteAs a vet who went to UMass Amherst on the GI Bill, I'm very well aware of the fun UMass has with tuition versus fees. Thanks for putting this together, it's a huge topic of discussion with the wife as to grad school costs.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your work on this blog. I am 31, got out of the Army after seven years active and am applying to schools this fall. You do great research and provide really good insights. This is helpful as I think about schools.
ReplyDeleteThe info on Harvard's age range is really interesting/distressing to a guy who is in that older range. That pretty much took Harvard off the board for me. I think I want to be around folks who are a little closer to my age with a little more experience. I'll be interested to hear about your experiences with the younger crowd.
Any thoughts on applying early to one school? Seems to me a school doesn't have much incentive to give you any scholarship/fellowship money if you've already told them you're coming their way.
Mark,
ReplyDeleteBest of luck in your applications. Don't be too discouraged by the age situation - obviously some people do get in. HBS has some of the toughest essays, so even if you don't get in, the HBS application might at least strengthen your other applications.
As far as early decision applications... I personally didn't go that route. It seems like a good way for schools to "lock in" candidates who could otherwise get into higher ranked schools otherwise... else what's in it for them? The advantage tilts to the candidate in my opinion if the school is really his #1 choice. If your number one choice takes early admissions, I think you should go for it. If it's not, I personally wouldn't commit myself before knowing how far I can make it.
If you're talking about just applying in the first round versus second round, that goes back to an old debate on first versus second round. I would refer you to my post on application strategy for more thoughts on that. Best of luck!
Just FYI, the max for MA was recently updated to $330:
ReplyDeletehttp://www.gibill.va.gov/GI_Bill_Info/CH33/Tuition_and_fees.htm
Makes both HBS and MIT more attractive :)
Great! Thanks for the update. I received an email from HBS just an hour after your post. I recalculated the numbers in the blog to reflect the change.
ReplyDeleteMilitaryToBusiness, can you shed some light on your military background, duty assignments, schooling, and experience? Great blog!
ReplyDeleteUnsatisfied, I appreciate your feedback and interest. I realize knowing my specific background may be of interest, but I am trying to keep this blog more about the HBS and transition experience, and less about me. I think the best way to transmit this knowledge is with as few biases as possible. This may change in the future, but for now, I'm trying not to keep things generic.
ReplyDeleteHello ...
ReplyDeleteMy name is Stacy H. I love how you talk about this in your blog ... I feel much passion for the business as much as I love eyelid surgery cost ... I love the subject and also keep me informed about this. I hope some day be a great businesswoman and develop in this area that I like.
Many thanks for your help ..
it's good to see this information in your post, i was looking the same but there was not any proper resource, thanx now i have the link which i was looking for my research.
ReplyDeleteMBA Dissertation Proposal
Great Post.
ReplyDeleteI am on active duty and my daughte just got accepted to Harvard Med School and I am benchmarking using your comprehensive analysis. Do you have any peripheral info you might share on what we should expect? I am assuming the new legislation in August should serve to standardize things somewhat with respect to methodology....but I still expect the points of frustration you identified will remain untreated.
Bottomline for me is that if we get 30K per year of assistance, I will be thrilled as I am still paying all the bills! :o)
Thanks for anything you can offer...
John
John,
ReplyDeleteRates have changed with the new law passed a few months ago. See the update here: http://militarytobusiness.blogspot.com/2010/12/post-911-gi-bill-update.html. You can expect around $35k/year in Cambridge for somebody entitled full 9/11 GI Bill, plus Yellow Ribbon benefits if the school offers it and if the student is entitled to it. At HBS, it's an additional $20k/year. I guess the main question is what your daughter is qualified for...